Repair vs Replace: Appliances
Every broken appliance raises the same question. This guide gives you a straightforward way to answer it: the half-cost rule, typical lifespans by appliance and the situations where repair or replacement usually wins. All numbers are typical estimates and general guidance, not guarantees for any single appliance. A diagnosis and upfront quote give you the real figure.

When a repair nears half the price of a comparable new appliance, compare the two.
If an appliance is near the end of its typical lifespan, a big repair is harder to justify.
A diagnosis and an upfront quote let you compare real numbers.
Prices on this page are typical estimated ranges for the Atlanta area, including common parts and labor. They are not quotes or guarantees. Your price depends on your model, the part that failed and its availability, and you get an upfront quote before repair begins.
Typical lifespans by appliance
These are general ranges. Care, usage and model quality all change them.
Refrigerator
Common parts are worth repairing early on. Sealed-system failures often point to replacement.
Washer
Pumps, belts and valves are worthwhile repairs. Bearing and tub failures often are not.
Dryer
Simple design makes most repairs good value, provided the vent is clear.
Dishwasher
Lower replacement cost means the comparison matters more.
Oven or range
Elements, igniters and sensors are usually worth fixing.
Microwave
Built-in and over-the-range models are often worth repairing. Basic countertop models often are not.
Lifespans are typical estimates, not guarantees. Many appliances last longer, and some fail sooner.
What to weigh in the decision
Use these together rather than relying on any single rule.
Repair quote versus new price
Get a written quote and compare it with a similar new appliance, including delivery and installation.
Age against typical lifespan
A repair on a young appliance pays back over many years. On an old one, it may not.
Type of failure
A single common part differs from a major component like a compressor, bearing or control board.
Repair history
Repeated repairs on one appliance are a sign it may be reaching the end.
Cost to replace
Built-in, panel-ready and premium appliances can cost far more, and they may need cabinet work.
Energy and features
Newer models may use less energy, but savings rarely cover the price of a new appliance on their own.
A simple way to decide
Run through both columns. The one that fits more of your situation usually points the way.
Repair usually wins when
- The appliance is in the first half or so of its typical life
- The failure is a single, common part
- The quote is well under half the price of a new one
- Replacing would mean cabinet, trim or installation costs
Replacement usually wins when
- The appliance is near or past its typical life span
- The quote is near or above half the cost of a new one
- A major component such as a compressor or bearing has failed
- It keeps breaking down
How to get the numbers you need
A good decision starts with a real quote.
Note the brand, model and age
The label inside the door or on the back lists the model and often the build date.
Get a diagnosis
A technician identifies the failed part so you are not guessing.
Get an upfront quote
We quote the repair before any work begins.
Compare and choose
Weigh the quote against a new appliance and decide with the facts.
Frequently Asked Questions
Straightforward answers about pricing, diagnostic fees, and appliance repair costs in Roswell.
Prices are typical estimates for general information only and are not a quote, offer or guarantee. Roswell GA Appliance Repair is an independent repair service and is not affiliated with any appliance manufacturer.



